Thanks to everyone for their support of this site event. It was really heart-warming to see people enthusiastic and wanting to be involved, even after the bad apple tried to ruin it by cheating. We've got such a strong and lovely community here, and I feel very fortunate to be a part of it. That said, here are the answers to the 20 riddles, and an explanation of why those were the answers (as some of them are a bit more obscure in their Neo-knowledge than others).
Answers:
1. I think a former Terror Mountain player may have gotten to these.
2. There were too close to 50 for TNT’s conservative sensibilities.
3. A food that belongs in Attack of the Revenge.
4. If she gives you one of these instead, you might worry that the Earth Faerie doesn’t like you.
5. My reptillioritus is flaring up!
6. This version is much cheaper, less effective in the battledome, and may melt.
7. If you’re feeling sad in Lord of the Flies, this would help you communicate it.
8. This petpet’s a good choice, if you’ve got the guts.
9. This is how rock stars style their ‘do.
10. This item is nothing to get hung about.
11. Proof that vegetables feel love too.
12. Wessle munched on these that fateful night.
13. Calling it a fruit is bad enough, but now a candy? Gross!
14. A true master doesn’t need to see the ball.
15. Some people just get so impatient for this holiday.
16. This jilted fellow has lost his bounce.
17. Garin would have be a goner if not for this.
18. That’s so intense! Woah man!
19. It’s pronounced “fish”, believe it or not.
20. You’ve undoubtedly seen this image a lot in your research for this hunt.
Those who PMed me their answers will shortly be receiving access to their new Scavenger Hunt userbar. Congratulations go to @(you need an account to see links) who had the highest score, getting 12 correct out of the 20. With a name like that, I'd expect nothing less than some good Neopets knowledge.
Results: