@(you need an account to see links)
Y'all are thinking of Leopets, actually! i used to be a user there long ago, but it looks like they wiped everyone's data since and i missed the memo to request transfer, so...boo. it let users submit their own pets and painted versions of them and whatnot, which is cool, but quality control was all over the board
still, pretty cool concept, i'm looking forward to neopetsclassic
as for features, a ton of great stuff's been said
i'd like 'other' gender for pets and the option to pick which eye style pets use, personally
ever since conversion, having female pets has been pretty fucking weird to me bc they all have...overt eyelashes and bedroom eyes, yuck
all they're missing is mandatory pink bows to make sure everyone knows she's a girl neopet, haha