If you could have ONE retired avatar you don't have....

[Alcremie]

TCG Wizard or Free Jhuidah, I really like the way those look

[Saturnine]

I really like the wraith ressurgence avatars, too bad I came back a few months after

[kittyray]

I think Coco Roller or the o_O Fire Faerie one. I'd have to think about it to pick. There are a bunch of more recent ones that I missed because I wasn't playing a lot at any given time, but those two I were active for, I just didn't have the right phone and I wasn't good at plots.

[Eed]

(you need an account to see links)

Probably this one.

[tox87]

TCG wizard or darigan darkling. I had darkling on an account that got frozen years ago. Still mad about that, because it was a relic of my favorite neopets plot.

[Guil]

This one soooo bad. I wish I knew English back then or how to even play Neopets. I could have had it

i played that game SO much trying to get it but i wasnt good enough, probably too dumb to understand it well enough as a kid lol

[j03]

Too many to list, but the most impressive and sought after one from my experience is "Fire Faerie" from the old/first? MI plot. There are actually three incredibly rare avatars from that event - Fire Faerie, I Saved MI, and Free Jhuidah.

I showcased a bunch of retired avatars from my account 4 years ago:

[tox87]

Those MI plot avs have got to be some of the rarest. Ancient plot with difficult puzzles, and they were rewarded to only a handful of people. I was playing while it was happening, and I still didn't get any of the avs.

[Flordibel]

It's not a plot-related one, but I dig Aishas and I love the colors in the Site Spotlight avvie!! It's crooked and cute... just look at it...

Sure hope they bring Site Spotlight back one day.

[Koto]

^ Easily the single avatar that I would give up a lot to get my grubby mitts on.