Seems like this method of not having votes and keeping the members to a minimum has worked well for the Guild.
I also want to believe that the people who get their info from cK put in the effort to do lotsa battles.
Now for the real question... what boon to pick from the Brutes :\ (since they all suck)
Edit:
Probably Right Round Round Round if you're still in it for the wheel avatars or Scratch Master if you buy scratch cards every time-reset as you'd be able to buy double.