Currently the items discovered so far are:
6 Handmade Leader Plushies:
Handmade Lanie & Lillie Plushie Set
Handmade Rasala the Bright Plushie
Handmade Duchess Plushie
Handmade Commander Flint Plushie
Handmade Master Thief Kanrik Plushie
Handmade Professor Lambert Plushie
6 Boss Keyrings:
Envy Keyring
Wrath Keyring
Pride Keyring
Apathy Keyring
Greed Keyring
Death Keyring
Other Prizes:
Mysterious Obelisk Stamp
Runes of the Obelisk
Helpful Zafara Digger
E-Z Brand My First Death Axe
Seeker Shield*
Ring of the Sway
Chess Set of Foreboding
Wand Of Lameness
Battle Beard
Thieves Hood
Rejuvenating Jar of Brains
A Shovel
Confused Wizard Action Figure
Bewitching Sorcerers Bonnet
The categories for the prizes are thought to be as follows:
Thieves:
Keyring - Greed Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Master Thief Kanrik Plushie
Wearable - Thieves Hood
Weapon -
Misc./Toy -
Sway:
Keyring - Pride Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Duchess Plushie
Wearable - Ring of the Sway (Unlikely)
Weapon - Ring of the Sway (Probably)
Misc./Toy - Chess Set of Foreboding
Order:
Keyring - Envy Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Rasala the Bright Plushie
Weapon - Wand Of Lameness
Wearable - Bewitching Sorcerers Bonnet
Misc./Toy - Confused Wizard Action Figure
Awakened:
Keyring - Death Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Lanie & Lillie Plushie Set
Wearable -
Weapon - E-Z Brand My First Death Axe
Misc./Toy - Rejuvenating Jar of Brains
Brutes:
Keyring - Wrath Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Commander Flint Plushie
Misc./Toy -
Wearable - Battle Beard (Probably)
Weapon - Battle Beard (Unlikely)
Seekers:
Keyring - Apathy Keyring
Plushie - Handmade Professor Lambert Plushie
Misc./Toy -
Wearable -
Weapon -