P90x or Insanity?

[lastdeadriser]

I think it's mostly about the diets on both though..
From what I've read most people didn't see any change until they did the diet plan.

that is the MOST important part

[thequeen]

so P90x then?....if you had to say just one over the other, which one?

[Blue]

im starting insanity monday i got it for free ill tell u how it goes if u want

[lakahus]

p90x is better in my opinion.

[Kristin]

I just started Insanity this week. I chose it because:
- the workouts are shorter (40 minutes). I don't have time to do the long P90x ones.
- no equipement needed. P90x requires weights.
- 60 days vs. 90 days for almost the same results.

But Ray-Chill was right when she said it's really important to be on some sort of diet plan when you do these.

[Bailey]

I've been doing insanity for 3 weeks now and I havent lost much lbs wise but I do notice a slimmer waist and more energy and I can do the workouts a lot more now than before. From what I've heard once you get into the second month of insanity the lbs really start coming off then, I really recommend insanity.

[Scarydark]

My coworker is a petite thing.
She said p90x made her arms look manly.
So she does insanity.

Ladies, you don't produce enough testosterone to ever look "manly".
Either or, it's just a personal preference. Try them both.
Or do your own "extreme" fitness program by doing compound lifting at your local gym with interval cardio.

One last thing...
Diet.

[Zildjian38]

From a woman's perspective, which one would tone the lower body more, without adding on unwanted bulk (muscle)? I'm not fat (in fact, I'm pretty thin), but I'm looking to just get fit for the summer and mostly tone my lower body (i.e, thighs).

Squats, bench, deadlift.

[Scarydark]

Squats, bench, deadlift.

This, use heavy and medium weight.

[shadow772]

I think P90X offer a body builder kind while Insanity gives an athletic look. personally, I go for Insanity because I prefer cardio workouts.